Front page
Archive
Silflay Hraka?


Bigwig is a systems administrator at a public university
Hrairoo is the proprietor of a quality used bookstore
Kehaar is.
Woundwort is a professor of counseling at a private university

The Hraka RSS feed

Email
bigwig AT nc.rr.com

Friends of Hraka
InstaPundit
Daily Pundit
cut on the bias
Meryl Yourish
This Blog Is Full Of Crap
Winds of Change
A Small Victory
Silent Running
Dr. Weevil
Little Green Footballs
ColdFury
Oceanguy
Fragments from Floyd
VodkaPundit
Allah
The Feces Flinging Monkey
Dean's World
Little Tiny Lies
The Redsugar Muse
Sperari
Natalie Solent
From the Mrs.
ErosBlog
The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
On the Third Hand
Public Nuisance
Not a Fish
Rantburg
AMCGLTD
WeckUpToThees!
Electric Venom
Skippy, The Bush Kangaroo
Common Sense and Wonder
Neither Here Nor There
Wizbang!
Bogieblog
ObscuroRant
RocketJones
The Greatest Jeneration
Ravenwolf
Ipse Dixit
TarHeelPundit
Blog On the Run
blogatron
Redwood Dragon
Notables
Greeblie Blog
Have A Cuppa Tea
A Dog's Life
IMAO
Zonitics.com
Iberian Notes
Midwest Conservative Journal
A Voyage to Arcturus
HokiePundit
Trojan Horseshoes
In Context
dcthornton.blog
The People's Republic of Seabrook
Country Store
Blog Critics
Chicago Boyz
Hippy Hill News
Kyle Still Free Press
The Devil's Excrement
The Fat Guy
War Liberal
Assume the Position
Balloon Juice
Iron Pen In A Velvet Glove
IsraPundit
Freedom Lives
Where Worlds Collide
Knot by Numbers
How Appealing
South Knox Bubba
Heretical Ideas
The Kitchen Cabinet
Dustbury.com
tonecluster
Bo Cowgill
mtpolitics.net
Raving Atheist
The Short Strange Trip
Shark Blog
Hoplites
Jimspot
Ron Bailey's Weblog
Cornfield Commentary
Testify!
Northwest Notes
pseudorandom
The Blog from the Core
Ain'tNoBadDude
CroMagnon
The Talking Dog
WTF Is It Now??
Blue Streak
Smarter Harper's Index
nikita demosthenes
Bloviating Inanities
Sneakeasy's Joint
Ravenwood's Universe
The Eleven Day Empire
World Wide Rant
All American
Pdawwg
The Rant
The Johnny Bacardi Show
The Head Heeb
Viking Pundit
Mercurial
Oscar Jr. Was Here
Just Some Poor Schmuck
Katy & Bruce Loebrich
But How's The Coffee?
Roscoe Ellis
Foolsblog
Sasha Castel
Dodgeblogium
Susskins Central Dispatch
DoggerelPundit
Josh Heit
Attaboy
Aaron's Rantblog
MojoMark
As I was saying...
Blog O' Dob
Dr. Frank's Blogs Of War
Betsy's Page
A Knob for Brightness
Fresh Bilge
The Politburo Diktat
Drumwaster's rants
Curt's Page
The Razor
An Unsealed Room
The Legal Bean
Helloooo chapter two!
As I Was Saying...
SkeptiLog AGOG!
Tong family blog
Vox Beth
Velociblog
I was thinking
Judicious Asininity
This Woman's Work
Fragrant Lotus
DaGoddess
Single Southern Guy
Caerdroia
GrahamLester.Com
Jay Solo's Verbosity
TacJammer
Snooze Button Dreams
Horologium
You Big Mouth, You!
From the Inside looking Out
Night of the Lepus
No Watermelons Allowed
From The Inside Looking Out
Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics
Suburban Blight
Aimless
The SmarterCop
Dog of Flanders
From Behind the Wall of Sleep
Beaker's Corner
Bad State of Gruntledness
Who Tends The Fires
Granny Rant
Elegance Against Ignorance
Moxie.nu
Eccentricity
Say What?
Blown Fuse
Wait 'til Next Year
The Pryhills
The Whomping Willow
The National Debate
The Skeptician
Zach Everson
MonkeyWatch
Geekward Ho
Argghhh!!!
Life in New Orleans
Rotten Miracles
Fringe
The Biomes Blog
illinigirl
See What You Share
Truthprobe
Blog d’Elisson
Your Philosophy Sucks
Watauga Rambler
Socialized Medicine
Consternations
Verging on Pertinence
Read My Lips
ambivablog
Soccerdad
The Flannel Avenger
Butch Howard's WebLog
Castle Argghhh!
Andrew Hofer
kschlenker.com
Moron Abroad
White Pebble
Darn Floor
Wizblog
tweedler
Pajama Pundits
BabyTrollBlog
Cadmusings
Goddess Training 101
A & W
Medical Madhouse
Slowly Going Sane
The Oubliette
American Future
Right Side Redux
See The Donkey
Newbie Trucker
The Right Scale
Running Scared
Ramblings Journal
Focus On Reality
Wyatt's Torch

June 24, 2003

Frank Burns Goes to Iraq

I will remember that there is art to medicine as well as science, and that warmth, sympathy, and understanding may outweigh the surgeon's knife or the chemist's drug.
........
I will remember that I remain a member of society, with special obligations to all my fellow human beings, those sound of mind and body as well as the infirm.
If I do not violate this oath, may I enjoy life and art, respected while I live and remembered with affection thereafter. May I always act so as to preserve the finest traditions of my calling and may I long experience the joy of healing those who seek my help.

--From the modern version of the Hippocratic Oath

While on duty in Iraq, Sgt. David Borell tried to get U.S. Army doctors to treat three injured Iraqi children, only to have them flatly refuse.

Maj. David Accetta, public affairs officer with the 3rd Corps Support Command, said the children's condition did not fall into a category that requires Army doctors to care for them. Only patients with conditions threatening life, limb or eyesight and not resulting from a chronic illness are considered for treatment.

“Our goal is for the Iraqis to use their own existing infrastructure and become self-sufficient, not dependent on U.S. forces for medical care,” Accetta said in an e-mail to AP.

Sorry, unacceptable. Adults are one thing, but if a child needs medical attention, you treat the child. You don't tell them "I can't treat your injuries because you need to use your own existing infrastructure," especially when we are supposedly trying to win over the population. Exactly how is refusing to treat this boy going to aid our mission in Iraq?

If you'd like to contact Major Accetta and explain this, or to ask for his version of the events covered in the story, his email address can be found here.

Update: Instapundit wrote about the same story a week or so ago.

I can see the sense of the general rule that Iraqis should treat Iraqis. What I object to is the refusal by the doctors to treat kids who are right there in from of them. It's callous, doesn't make any sense, and gives the impression that for the doctors winning over Iraqis is rather a low priority.

Posted by Bigwig at June 24, 2003 12:49 PM | TrackBack
Postscript:
First time visitor to House Hraka? Wondering if everything we produce could possibly be as brilliant/stupid/evil/pedantic/insipid/inspired as the post you just read? Check out the Hraka Essentials, the (mostly) reader-selected guide to Hraka's best posts, and decide for yourself.
Comments

Most importantly, it is a violation of the Hippocratic oath.

Posted by: Mrs. du Toit at June 24, 2003 01:30 PM

Mainly in the interest of the Devil's advocate, what do we expect would happen if the US doctors treated every child that came in front of them, who was not suffering from a condition that threatened "life, limb, or sight"?

The natural thing I'd expect is for every child in Iraq within travel distance of a US doctor, with anything medically wrong with them, to be in front of a US doctor as soon as physically possible, resulting in a complete overloading of US medical personnel and logistics.

It may be callous in the immediate but non-callous in the long-term consequences, which are to cause the Iraqis to not be dependent on US medical personnel. Of course, the US should be providing whatever supplies it possibly can to Iraqi medical personnel, but that's another matter. As far as I know, Iraq has a reasonable number of adequately trained doctors, with more every week as expatriates return home to rebuild the country; with US (and EU, hint hint to France and Germany) supplies, I see no reason why they should not be able to treat the vast majority of the nation's injured (but not qualified under policy to get US doctors) adequately.

Evidently, if the pictured child was not treated, one assumes his injuries were not life threatening or crippling (or the stated policy is not being followed, which is another argument entirely).

Thus ends the devil's advocate portion of this post.

Personally, I'm withholding any further judgement of right or wrong until more specifics of the GENERAL situation are at hand, rather than one case in one place, before condemning the entire military medical establishment and the policy in general, which seems necessary, as above, to prevent total overloading of the infrastructure.

Doctors should probably have more discretion to treat Iraqis who are not in imminent danger of death (and I suspect many DO, in fact, do so, ignoring Policy)... but no matter how many they treat, someone will eventually be turned away, either as a necessary measure to prevent overloading, or BECAUSE of overloading if such measures aren't taken.

Most likely (not knowing the level of load at the medical facility in question - perhaps it was already overloaded or at 99% capacity? No data available) the kids in question should have been treated. That would be better PR and "heart and mind" winning... but, while it's "callous" to say so, it's still true that there are strict limits to what US doctors can and should do, given that demand for services almost certainly exceeds capacity.

I sympathise as much as anyone who's never been horribly burned can with these kids (even putting aside my "what the fuck did they think they were doing setting a bag of explosives on fire" question - kids all around the world do bone-stupid stuff all the time, and they shouldn't suffer for it if it can be helped), but I don't think it's wise to base policy decisions on the emotional appeal of injured children, no matter what the decision is.

Posted by: Sigivald at June 24, 2003 05:08 PM

Wow, that ended up being really long.

Posted by: Sigivald at June 24, 2003 05:11 PM

Wrong. We *should* do something to help the people who are right in front of us. To do otherwise is callous and inhumane. You are arguing like the Pharisee - too holy to treat the wounded man.

This Samaritan would help whom he could.

Also, are you really saying that the richest nation on earth can't afford to treat a few children in Iraq?

Get yourself some humanity man.

Posted by: Larry Lurex at June 25, 2003 06:44 AM

What's up with the picture of the kid with the napalm burn? (Well, it may just be petrol. Same thing, really). We saw a bunch of that in GW I, inflicted on the Iraqis when Saddam's brave commandos blew up a massive tank farm, in which thousands of Iraqi refugees had camped. We were treating burns for days.

Also, playing devil's advocate, from what I've seen on the news, many Iraqis are doing jack shit to help rebuild their country, even when they have the time and ability to do some work. A recent story about the war casualties, checking on the hospitals around Baghdad, reported that the hospitals are mostly empty. More info, please.

Posted by: omnibus bill at June 25, 2003 10:20 AM
Post a comment Note: Comments with more than two dashes per line will be blocked as spam.









Remember personal info?